top of page
“ For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world ”
Moloch: God of Destructive Game Theory
the god of destructive competition (coordination failure, negative-sum game theory) and means-ends-reversal - the sacrifice of value (the good, the true and the beautiful) for survival and power. Moloch is transcendent and immanent; we are Moloch and Moloch is us, it becomes us and we become it, we act it out and it acts through us. We 'metaphorically' attribute causality and responsibility to an emergent demonic entity (‘it was Moloch that did it’) when no such entity actually exists; and yet ‘it’ effects the world as if it does. In this way, Moloch is an alienation of our individual and collective agency.
Structure of Moloch
Negative-Sum Game theory: In game theory, a negative-sum game is a scenario where the sum of the payoffs to all players is less than zero; in other words, the "pie" shrinks as the game is played. Unlike zero-sum games (where one wins what the other loses), here, conflict or competition destroys value for everyone involved. A classic example is a nuclear war or a price war that bankrupts all competitors.
Coordination Failure: This occurs when a group of agents could achieve a desirable outcome by cooperating but fail to do so because they cannot coordinate their strategies or trust one another. It is the mechanism behind the Prisoner’s Dilemma: even though "Mutual Cooperation" is the best collective outcome, the rational individual incentive to "Defect" leads the group to a suboptimal equilibrium where everyone is worse off.
Means-Ends Reversal (critical theory): Also known as "instrumental rationality," this describes a pathological inversion where the means (tools, systems, efficiency, profit) displace the ends (human well-being, happiness, truth). The system ceases to serve human goals and instead, humans begin to serve the maintenance of the system. We optimize for metrics (like GDP or engagement) that were meant to measure the good, eventually sacrificing the actual good to maximize the metric.
The Rise & Fall of Goliath
Reverse Extended Mind Thesis & Reverse Prostheticisation: The "Extended Mind Thesis" says our tools (smartphones, notebooks) are extensions of our minds. Reverse Prostheticisation argues the inverse: in hyper-optimized systems, humans become extensions of the tool. We become the "prosthetic limbs" of the algorithm or the bureaucracy, executing its logic because the system cannot act in the physical world without us. We do not use the machine; the machine uses us to reproduce itself.
Emergent Agency (Strong Emergentism): This concept suggests that complex systems can exhibit goal-directed behavior ("agency") that is not present in any of the individual parts. Just as a single neuron has no "thought" but a brain does, a civilization or market can "want" things (like growth or self-preservation) that no individual human within it actually wants. The system itself becomes a "super-agent" that acts upon the world, often overruling the desires of its constituent members.
Philosophy of Science, Religion & Economics
Alienation (Marx & Fauerbach): Ludwig Feuerbach argued that "God" is just a projection of the best human qualities onto an external, imaginary being, leaving humanity feeling empty ("alienated") of those qualities. Karl Marx applied this to economics: under capitalism, humans project their creative power into Capital. The market—a human creation—confronts its creators as an alien, unstoppable force that dictates their lives. We build the machine, then bow down to it as if it were a force of nature.
Theological & Metaphysical Stages (Comte's Law of the Three Stages): Auguste Comte proposed that society evolves through three stages of explanation: Theological (attributing events to gods), Metaphysical (attributing events to abstract forces like "Nature" or "The Market"), and Positive (scientific understanding). In the context of Moloch, we often regress to a "Metaphysical" stage, treating coordination failures not as solvable engineering problems but as the inevitable dictates of abstract, quasi-divine forces like "The Invisible Hand" or "Geopolitics."
Moloch as Real Abstraction & Real God: Drawing on the philosophy of "Real Abstraction" (Sohn-Rethel, Žižek), this argues that Moloch is not physically real, but is socially real. Because everyone acts as if the constraints of the market/system are absolute, those abstractions gain causal power equivalent to physical laws. Moloch is a "god" not because he exists in the sky, but because he demands and receives actual human sacrifice (time, values, lives) in exchange for worldly success.
God of the Gaps: Traditionally, this refers to using God to explain what science hasn't yet solved. In a systems context, Moloch is the God of the Explanatory Gaps in sociology. When we see a disaster (like a financial crash or war) that no individual wanted and no specific person planned, we attribute the causality to "Moloch." It is the name we give to the dark matter of sociology—the invisible structural forces that generate outcomes distinct from human intent.
History of Moloch
Moloch (Meditations on Moloch, Alexander): In Scott Alexander’s seminal essay, Moloch is identified as the principle of multi-polar traps. Alexander helps us see that the terrifying entity demanding sacrifice is not a specific villain, but the mathematical inevitability of incentive structures. He argues that unless we solve the coordination problem (kill Moloch), the competitive pressure to sacrifice safety for power will eventually lead to existential catastrophe (likely via AI or biology).
Moloch (Howl!, Ginsberg): In Allen Ginsberg’s poem, Moloch is the industrial-capitalist machine that eats the soul of the youth. He cries, "Moloch whose mind is pure machinery! Moloch whose blood is running money!" Here, Moloch represents the crushing weight of a society obsessed with war, stone, and profit, which destroys the "angelheaded hipsters"—the creative, spiritual, and human elements of the generation.
Moloch (Metropolis, Lang): In Fritz Lang’s 1927 film, Moloch is depicted literally as a monstrous industrial furnace. In a hallucination, the protagonist sees the great machine morph into a demonic idol where workers are marched into its fiery mouth to keep the city running. It is the ultimate visual metaphor for the system that consumes human life as fuel to sustain the gleaming utopia above.
bottom of page